Eur Urol. 2015 Oct;68(4):674–80.
Erectile dysfunction (ED) is a major health care problem worldwide and phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors (PDE5Is) are the pharmacological treatment of choice. However, the optimal PDE5I for ED treatment is not known.
To investigate trade-offs between efficacy and adverse events for various PDE5Is in treating ED.
EVIDENCE ACQUISITION :
A review was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Statement. Medline, Scopus, reference lists of relevant articles, and systematic reviews were searched. Eligible studies were randomized controlled trials comparing at least one PDE5I for treating ED with placebo or another PDE5I.
EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS :
We included 82 trials (47 626 patients) for efficacy analysis and 72 trials (20 325 patients) for adverse event analysis. In the trade-off analysis of starting dosages, sildenafil 50mg had the greatest efficacy but also had the highest rate of overall adverse events. Tadalafil 10mg had intermediate efficacy but had the lowest overall rate of all adverse events. Vardenafil 10mg and avanafil 100mg had similar overall adverse events than sildenafil 50mg but a markedly lower global efficacy. Udenafil 100mg had similar global efficacy to that of tadalafil 10mg but its overall adverse event rates were higher.
This is the first trade-off analysis of the different PDE5Is currently available. For individuals who prioritize high efficacy, sildenafil 50mg appears to be the treatment of choice. Men wishing to optimize tolerability should take tadalafil 10mg or switch to udenafil 100mg in the case of insufficient efficacy.
- VIAGRA comprimé pelliculé 25, 50 et 100 mg
- VIZARSIN comprimé orodispersible 25, 50 et 100 mg
- VIZARSIN comprimé pelliculé 25, 50 et 100 mg
- REVATIO comprimé pelliculé 20 mg
- REVATIO poudre pour suspension buvable 10 mg/ml
- REVATIO solution injectable 0,8 mg/ml
- SILDENAFIL 25, 50 et 100 mg (Nombreux génériques)
- LEVITRA comprimé pelliculé 5, 10 mg et 20 mg
- LEVITRA comprimé orodispersible 10 mg
- VIVANZA comprimé pelliculé 5, 10 mg et 20 mg
- CIALIS comprimé pelliculé 2,5, 5, 10 mg et 20 mg
- SPEDRA comprimé 50,100 et 200 mg
- ZYDENA 50, 75 et 100 mg : non commercialisé en France (11/2015)